Home of Gaston LeSnort —
judging you daily.
-
Snortwear
-
Normal Society
- French Bulldog Blog
- T-Shirt Care
- Contact
The fundamental difference between SturdiBag and Sherpa carriers lies in their approach to height flexibility. SturdiBag employs a patented system of flexible rods that run throughout the carrier's structure, allowing for uniform vertical compression while maintaining the carrier's overall integrity. These rods can be removed entirely for washing and storage, then easily reinstalled to restore the carrier's shape.
Sherpa takes a different approach with their spring wire frame system, which focuses compression at specific points rather than distributing it evenly. The spring wire frame allows the rear panel and ends of the carrier to compress several inches when pushed down, creating the necessary clearance for under-seat storage. This targeted compression method maintains rigidity in the carrier's main body while providing flexibility where needed most.
French Bulldogs face unique travel restrictions due to their flat-nosed anatomy. Airlines generally prohibit brachycephalic breeds from cargo travel because their compressed airways make them vulnerable to overheating and oxygen deprivation in the cargo hold's variable conditions. This restriction makes in-cabin travel not just preferable, but often the only viable option for French Bulldog owners.
The in-cabin requirement creates additional pressure on carrier selection, as the carrier must meet strict airline dimensional requirements while providing adequate space and ventilation for a breed already prone to breathing difficulties. Le Snort recognizes these unique challenges facing French Bulldog families and provides expert guidance on airline travel requirements.
Airline seat configurations vary dramatically across carriers and aircraft types. Delta recommends maximum dimensions of 18" x 11" x 11", while United's Boeing 737 MAX aircraft impose a strict 10-inch height limit. Southwest's 737-700 series presents yet another set of spatial constraints. These variations mean that a carrier with fixed dimensions might work perfectly on one airline but fail to fit on another.
The unpredictability extends beyond just different airlines. Even within the same airline, different aircraft models create varying under-seat spaces. A carrier that fits comfortably under a wide-body aircraft seat might struggle to fit under the more restrictive confines of a regional jet. This reality makes flexible height capability necessary rather than merely convenient.
SturdiBag's flexible rod system creates what users describe as "smooshiness" - the ability to compress vertically while maintaining structural support. The flexible rods bend under pressure rather than breaking or permanently deforming, allowing the carrier to conform to tight spaces while springing back to full height when pressure is released.
This compression happens gradually and evenly across the carrier's surface. When sliding the carrier under a seat, the top compresses first, followed by progressive compression throughout the height of the carrier. The pet inside experiences minimal disruption as the space gradually adjusts rather than suddenly collapsing at specific points.
SturdiBag offers multiple size options suitable for French Bulldogs, with the Large size accommodating pets up to 30 pounds and the Extra Large supporting up to 40 pounds. The Cube size works for smaller Frenchies up to 20 pounds, though most adult French Bulldogs will require the Large size for comfortable travel.
The SturdiBag Large has proven successful for French Bulldogs in real-world airline travel scenarios. However, the XL and XXL sizes are not airline-compliant for in-cabin travel, making the Large size the practical upper limit for air travel with larger French Bulldogs.
Sherpa's spring wire frame creates targeted compression zones rather than uniform flexibility. The rear panel can compress several inches when pushed, while the spring wire frame at the ends of the carrier provides additional give. This design maintains a more rigid structure in the main body of the carrier while allowing strategic compression where airline seats typically create the most space constraints.
The spring mechanism works by allowing specific sections to flatten while keeping other areas stable. This approach can be beneficial for pets who prefer a more stable environment, as the main living space remains relatively unchanged while only the edges compress to meet airline requirements.
Sherpa backs their carriers with a "Guaranteed On Board" program that reimburses flight costs and pet fees if passengers are denied boarding due to carrier size issues, provided all guidelines are followed. This program reflects Sherpa's confidence in their carriers' airline compliance and provides peace of mind for travelers concerned about potential boarding complications.
The guarantee requires following specific guidelines, including checking with the airline beforehand and ensuring the pet meets all carrier requirements. While this doesn't eliminate the stress of potential boarding issues, it does provide financial protection for travelers who experience problems despite following proper procedures.
French Bulldogs' compressed airways make ventilation a safety factor rather than just a comfort consideration. Adequate airflow helps prevent the overheating that brachycephalic breeds are prone to, especially in the stress-inducing environment of air travel.
SturdiBag's All Mesh variant excels in this area with extensive mesh panels on all sides, providing maximum airflow and visibility. The mesh construction allows air to circulate freely around the pet, while the top zipper access enables owners to provide water and reassurance during the journey without removing the pet from the carrier.
Most adult French Bulldogs fall into the 20-30 pound range, creating unique challenges for in-cabin travel. Many airlines impose combined weight limits of 17 pounds (8kg) including both pet and carrier, which can exclude larger French Bulldogs from certain airlines entirely.
The size requirements create a delicate balance between providing adequate space for a medium-sized dog while keeping the carrier compact enough for airline compliance. French Bulldogs need sufficient room to lie down comfortably and change positions during longer flights, but excessive space can actually increase stress by making the pet feel insecure.
French Bulldogs benefit from being able to see their owners during travel, as visual contact helps reduce anxiety. Mesh panels serve dual purposes by providing ventilation and maintaining visual connection between pet and owner. The ability to see out also helps pets adjust to the changing environment during boarding and takeoff.
Comfort features like washable fleece pads become especially important for longer flights. French Bulldogs' tendency to drool and their sensitivity to temperature changes make easy-to-clean, comfortable bedding necessary for a successful travel experience.
Direct testing under Southwest 737-700 aircraft seats revealed important practical differences between the two carrier systems. Both the Large SturdiBag and Sherpa Delta Deluxe successfully fit under the seats, but their performance characteristics differed significantly.
The SturdiBag's even compression allowed for smoother sliding under the seat, while maintaining better internal space distribution. The Sherpa's targeted compression worked effectively but created some uneven internal space as certain areas compressed more than others. The Sherpa's design features may limit visibility into the carrier depending on the specific model configuration, making it more difficult for owners to check on their pets during the flight.
Both carriers maintained their structural integrity throughout the flight, but the SturdiBag's flexibility made retrieval easier when deplaning, as it compressed readily when pulled from under the seat. The Sherpa required more careful maneuvering due to its more rigid construction in non-compression areas.
For French Bulldog owners prioritizing maximum ventilation and flexible compression, SturdiBag's design offers clear advantages. The All Mesh variant specifically addresses the ventilation needs vital for brachycephalic breeds, while the flexible rod system provides smooth, even compression under varying airline seat configurations.
The SturdiBag's ability to compress uniformly while maintaining internal space makes it particularly suitable for French Bulldogs who need consistent airflow and comfortable positioning during travel. The washable design and removable components also make maintenance easier for owners dealing with the additional cleaning requirements that come with flat-nosed breeds.
While both carriers meet basic airline requirements, SturdiBag's engineering specifically addresses the unique needs of breeds like French Bulldogs who face additional health considerations during air travel. The combination of superior ventilation, even compression, and practical features like top zipper access creates a travel solution designed with brachycephalic breed safety in mind.
For French Bulldog families seeking expert guidance on airline travel requirements and carrier selection, Le Snort provides specialized resources and recommendations tailored specifically to French Bulldog needs.
Is your French Bulldog's drooling just a quirky trait, or could it signal a life-threatening emergency? While their flat faces naturally cause more drool, certain patterns—especially when paired with specific symptoms—demand immediate action that could save your Frenchie's life.
While French Bulldogs are adored globally for their playful temperaments and iconic, flat-faced looks, these endearing traits come with a serious medical reality. It is crucial for both current and prospective owners to understand that bringing a Frenchie into the world is not a natural process. Unlike most breeds, their breeding and delivery require intense veterinary intervention that goes far beyond standard canine reproduction.
Planning to bring home a French Bulldog puppy? You might be surprised to learn that what appears to be a fully-grown dog at 9 months is actually only 90% developed—and the real transformation happens in the months that follow.
